Posts : 798 Join date : 2011-06-20 Location : Rehoboth, MA
Subject: WHINE: One Bad Apple Sat Nov 24, 2012 3:16 pm
You know the spoiler rules! No discussion for 24 hours! Keep everything under a spoiler tag until then.
Spoiler:
Ok, so here we go...
Babs' accent has to be the most atrocious Brooklyn accent ever. XD
The Bad Seed song is really cute. I really can't wait to hear some remixes of it.
OMFG...Sweetie Belle crying is just a little bit less traumatic than Fluttershy crying. D:
THE MOTHERFRAKING A-TEAM THEME SONG (ish)!
It ended pretty much how I expected. It was a solid episode all in all.
out of
~D
Derpy Mane
Posts : 1195 Join date : 2011-10-10 Location : England, Russia or Czech
Subject: Re: WHINE: One Bad Apple Sat Nov 24, 2012 4:54 pm
Spoiler:
THE CUTIE MARKS CRUSADERS A-TEAM So much under age arse...and such countless macros that will ensue It be funny if Derpy was sitting next to Whooves at the theatre, in fact Depry was MIA even with so many crowd scenes..that makes me a saaaad pony. Babs was bad and now she's baaaad Pinkie Pie is in there for less than a minute and just excels. Defying cartoon physics (because normal physics are just too...normal), lettuce in, don't leaf me, veggie salad...I don't even. Good message about the bullied becoming bullies though, pretty enjoyable overall but probably the low point of the season...but that's easy considering its only 4 so far)
Pinkie Pie Event Mane
Posts : 742 Join date : 2011-06-25 Location : Indianapolis, IN
Subject: Re: WHINE: One Bad Apple Sat Nov 24, 2012 5:19 pm
Spoiler:
Skarkdahn Colt
Posts : 188 Join date : 2011-12-13 Location : United Kingdom
Subject: Re: WHINE: One Bad Apple Sat Nov 24, 2012 8:02 pm
Spoiler:
I really don't know what to think of this one. Firstly, it needs to be said that Sweetie Belle instantly gains more points in the "Best CMC" scoreboard. She easily gains one of the best lines in the episode, and actually acts the most mature of the three - heck, if the others had listened to her and talked to AJ, maybe they'd have understood Babs earlier and easier? Also AB and Scoot running away from their problems because they're frightened of name-calling. Sweetie now also gains second place in the leaderboard of "Characters you never ever want to see cry ever in MLP:FiM", just behind Fluttershy. That song is damn catchy. Also Sweetie Belle with that shake; that filly is damn adorable. I thought Silver Spoon had improved upon her first and snobbish appearance when she clapped first for Granny Smith in FAD. Now, all respect points have been lost. All of them. Shame on you, Spoon. Shame on you. I do like the idea of Babs bullying only to avoid being bullied. Nothing truly new there, but it's an interesting character dynamic to explore in this show. Speaking of Babs, she's characterised rather well. Yes, we're probably meant to find her annoying, but then of course when her insecurity comes out it definitely shows that she has fears. Also that scene of her leaving the train really executes unsureness and awkwardness at stepping off a train at a place you've never been to and immediately being swamped by your overexcited cousin and her equally excited friends. Small detail, but it's a good inclusion. Conversely, the revelation that SS and DT have fears is not used for feels but for comedy. I must admit I did say "take that!" when that happened.
Like all episodes, it could have been better. I won't elaborate, but it also had its brilliant bits. I'd give it a 6.5/10
crazyBE Unicorn
Posts : 881 Join date : 2011-12-20 Location : Belgium
Subject: Re: WHINE: One Bad Apple Sat Nov 24, 2012 8:45 pm
Spoiler:
I think Babs just went to the Dark Side.... ...of the Force
Subject: WHINE: One Bad Apple 
Sat Nov 24, 2012 3:16 pm
